Asphalt vs. Metal Roofing in Colorado Weather

The two materials we install most often are architectural asphalt and standing-seam metal. Tile shows up occasionally on higher-end builds, and synthetic slate on a handful of historic-overlay homes, but for the typical Front Range house the choice is between those two.

Here is the honest comparison.

What asphalt does well

A well-installed architectural asphalt roof on a typical Colorado Springs home will last twenty to twenty-five years. The shingles weigh about three hundred pounds per square (a square is one hundred square feet of coverage), they install fast, they handle the temperature swings, and they are forgiving on roofs with multiple penetrations.

The price is the other strong suit. A typical residential asphalt reroof on a 25-square home runs roughly $13,000 to $19,000 installed, depending on tear-off complexity, the number of layers being removed, and the slope. That is the cheapest path to a new code-compliant roof on a Colorado house.

The downside is hail. Architectural asphalt has improved dramatically over the past decade, and Class 4 impact-rated shingles (the kind we install by default) survive most non-catastrophic hail events. But a three-inch hailstone driven by a strong updraft will still bruise an asphalt shingle. The shingle does not fail immediately; it just starts losing granules in the impact zone, and the underlying asphalt slowly oxidizes from there. That is why most asphalt-roof insurance claims show up six to eighteen months after the storm rather than the day of.

What metal does well

Standing-seam metal is the right answer in a few specific situations. The first is the roof you intend to keep for forty years; metal lasts roughly twice as long as asphalt and pays back the cost premium over the second half of that lifespan. The second is the roof you want to genuinely shrug off Colorado hail; metal panels dent visibly under hail but the structural integrity is unchanged, and the dents only matter cosmetically. The third is the high-altitude home where snow load is a recurring concern; standing-seam panels shed snow on their own without ice-dam buildup.

The downside is the up-front cost. A standing-seam metal reroof on the same 25-square home runs roughly $32,000 to $48,000 installed, plus another $2,000 to $4,000 if the existing decking needs replacement to support the panel system. That is two to three times the asphalt number.

A second downside, less talked about: metal is loud during a hailstorm. Modern installations include a synthetic underlayment that dampens the sound considerably, but the comparison to asphalt is real. If your bedroom is directly under the roof and you sleep light, ask us about acoustic-rated underlayment when we quote.

The math over twenty years

A common back-of-napkin comparison runs like this. Asphalt at $16,000 lasts twenty years, so the per-year cost is $800. Metal at $40,000 lasts forty years, so the per-year cost is $1,000. The metal premium is $200 a year, which is roughly the difference in homeowners insurance you would pay over that span if your asphalt roof took a major hail hit and the deductible came out of your pocket.

The math gets more interesting if you live in a hail corridor (most of El Paso County qualifies) and your insurance has a separate, higher hail deductible. Two unrelated hail events over the life of an asphalt roof can erase the up-front savings entirely. Metal is the right choice for a homeowner who does not want to think about the roof again until they sell the house.

Which one we recommend

For a typical Colorado Springs home where the homeowner expects to be in the house for the foreseeable future and wants the cheapest path to a code-compliant new roof, we recommend Class 4 architectural asphalt. It is the standard for a reason, the warranty work is straightforward, and the pricing is transparent.

For a homeowner who is staying long-term, has been through a hail claim already, or is building new and willing to pay up front for the lifetime advantage, metal is genuinely the better material. We will not push it on someone who is not ready for the price tag, but we install it cleanly and warrant it for the panel manufacturer's full term.

If you are trying to decide between the two, the inspection is free and the conversation is honest. We have been wrong about this before; the only way to be right about your specific roof is to look at it.

---

← Back to all articles